1. Home
  2. Homeowners Insurance

Find the Best Homeowners Insurance in Tallahassee, FL

Home insurance provides coverage for your home, personal belongings and liability. Having a policy is not always required, but nearly all homeowners in Florida purchase one to protect their largest investment. To help you find a policy that balances financial protection with affordable premiums, we researched the best homeowners insurance in Tallahassee.

Compare Tallahassee Homeowners Insurance

Overall satisfaction rating
  • Quotes from local agents and top insurers
  • Compare the lowest rates
  • Fast and free for homeowners
  • Available in Tallahassee
Learn More
Overall satisfaction rating
  • #1 in online home insurance quotes
  • Additional coverage options
  • Covers other structures on your property
  • Available in Tallahassee
Learn More Read More
State Farm
Overall satisfaction rating
  • Home security discounts
  • Condo unit insurance
  • Home inventory tools
  • Available in Tallahassee
Learn More Read More

How to choose homeowners insurance in Tallahassee

Tallahassee skyline

About 56 percent of households in Tallahassee are homeowners, according to census data and the U.S. Department of Housing and Urban Development.

If you are among the tens of thousands of homeowners in Florida’s capital, you need homeowners insurance to protect from financial loss in case your physical home is damaged or destroyed, your personal property is damaged or stolen or you are legally responsible for an accident.

Homeowners insurance in Tallahassee usually comes standard with these coverages:

  • Dwelling, which covers your home
  • Other structures, which covers detached garages, sheds and fences
  • Personal property, which covers your personal contents, like clothes, furniture and electronics
  • Personal liability, which covers a claim or lawsuit resulting from damage to someone else’s property or a bodily injury
  • Additional living expenses, which covers expenses above and beyond what you’re used to paying if a covered event forces you out of your home
  • Medical payments, which covers medical bills of someone accidentally injured on your property

When you buy homeowners insurance in Tallahassee, be aware that each coverage has limits the insurance company will pay out. It’s important to insure your home for the cost to rebuild it with the current prices of materials and labor. You should also do an inventory of your belongings and assets to determine if personal property and liability coverages are enough.

The most popular and comprehensive type of policy covers losses from any cause that is not specifically mentioned as an exclusion. But another type specifically lists covered events. Homeowners insurance in Tallahassee often protects you from financial loss resulting from:

  • Fire or smoke
  • Lightning
  • Windstorm or hail
  • Theft or vandalism
  • Weight of ice, snow or sleet
  • Explosions or riots
  • Aircraft or vehicle crashes
  • Catastrophic ground cover collapse

Cost of homeowners insurance in Tallahassee

On average, Florida homeowners pay the highest homeowners insurance premiums in the country. The exact cost of a policy depends on various factors, like the age and construction materials of your home, the amount of coverage you buy, your credit and loss history, if you have pets and the neighborhood where you live.

Average yearly home insurance rates in Tallahassee

$200,000 dwelling $400,000 dwelling $600,000 dwelling
Midtown (32303) $1,191 $2,209 $3,239
Betton Hills (32308) $1,191 $2,209 $3,239
Killearn (32309) $1,191 $2,209 $3,239
Southwood (32311) $1,193 $2,213 $3,246
Waverly Hills (32312) $1,191 $2,209 $3,239
Avondale (32317) $1,191 $2,209 $3,239
Note: Based on dwelling coverage above with a constant $1,000 deductible and $100,000 liability.

Don’t purchase homeowners insurance in Tallahassee without knowing your deductible and if you have replacement cost or actual cash value coverage. Replacement cost is the amount you need to repair or replace your property at today’s prices. Actual cash value coverage will take depreciation into account.

Compare quotes from several different companies. Ask an agent what discounts are available. You can save money with most insurers by bundling policies or having home safety systems, like smoke detectors.

Make sure you ask about flood and sinkhole protection. If you have high-value personal items, you should inquire about additional coverage as well.

Homeowners Insurance Reviews


Progressive offers free homeowners insurance quotes with the coverages you need and has agents standing by to help. Tallahassee shoppers can use HomeQuote Explorer, an online tool allowing you to compare rates and coverages from multiple companies. Florida reviewers like how many ways there are to save on a homeowners insurance policy from Progressive.

Progressive Learn More

State Farm

State Farm is one of the top U.S. home insurers. Visit the company’s website to read State Farm’s Simple Insights, like how to create a home inventory to make coverage decisions. Policy discounts are available for bundling, having home monitoring systems or using impact-resistant roofing products. Tallahassee residents say State Farm is a dependable insurer with a straightforward claims process.

State Farm Learn More


Homeowners insurance from GEICO includes a full range of protections. Start the quote process online or reach a sales agent for assistance buying a policy that meets your needs and budget. Save with multipolicy and home security discounts. Tallahassee residents like the affordable premiums and speak highly of GEICO’s customer service.