1. Home
  2. Mattresses

Find the Best Mattresses in Tallahassee, FL

A great mattress does much more than give you a good night's sleep. It also supports and cushions your frame to alleviate pain and stiffness. The best mattress for your individual needs depends on what kind of sleeper you are, the amount of support your body needs and your budget. We researched the best mattress stores in Tallahassee so you can find restful slumber.

Compare Top Mattresses

Accredited Partner
Saatva Mattress
Overall satisfaction rating
  • Made in the USA
  • Lumbar support enhancement
  • Eco-friendly materials
  • Available in Tallahassee

The Ultimate in Comfort and Luxury

Learn More (877) 672-2882 Read More
Overall satisfaction rating
  • 3 and 4 layer mattress systems
  • 100 night in-home trial
  • 3 comfort choices: plush, medium, firm
  • Available in Tallahassee

Luma Sleep is committed to helping its customers sleep happily ever after. Luma Sleep is a luxury mattress company that provides its customers with personal comfort choices before and after they purchase a Luma mattress system. Luma’s unique 2-layer mattresses provide customers the ability to change the comfort layer if they decide the bed is not perfect for them - for FREE. Also, 100-night free in-home trial; free shipping & returns.

Learn More (813) 956-3765 Read More
Select Comfort - Sleep Number
Overall satisfaction rating
  • Dual comfort adjustability on both sides
  • SleepIQ® technology tracks how you sleep
  • 100-night trial
  • Pressure-relieving comfort layers
Read More
Overall satisfaction rating
  • Stays cool, disperses body heat and allows airflow
  • Adapts to your pressure points
  • Made in the USA
  • 100-night risk-free trial
Learn More Read More
Overall satisfaction rating
  • 4 layers of premium foam
  • High airflow for breathability
  • High airflow for breathability
  • Durable dog beds
Learn More Read More
Overall satisfaction rating
  • 365-night, risk-free trial
  • Plush but supportive medium-firm mattress
  • Works with all bed frames
  • Certified, flexible, non-toxic foam

Nectar sells one medium-firm mattress model that has excellent support, making it a great choice for back sleepers. It is manufactured with a cooling cover, gel memory foam, adaptive memory foam and a base layer. The mattress also comes with a 365-night sleep trial, and shipping and returns are free.

Learn More Read More

How to choose a mattress in Tallahassee


If tossing and turning in bed has become a familiar routine, a better mattress will help you get a better night’s rest.

Research shows that medium-firm mattresses reduce lower back pain because they contour to your body and keep your spine aligned. A soft mattress, on the other hand, hugs your body and is a better choice for side sleepers because it cushions their pressure points. A firm mattress gives you the feeling of sleeping on the mattress rather than sinking into it and works best for stomach sleepers or heavier individuals.

In addition to different levels of firmness, mattresses are available in multiple styles constructed from different materials. Like firmness, no one type is best for everyone, but knowing the features of each helps you decide which is best for you.

Mattress types in Tallahassee

Mattress type Description Best for... Average cost for a queen-size mattress
Innerspring/coil mattress Made with metal springs evenly distributed throughout the mattress to support your body All sleepers $950
Memory foam mattress Contains several layers of foam and gradually contours to your body while sleeping Side and back sleepers $900
Latex mattress Similar to a memory foam mattress but constructed from latex instead of synthetic materials Side and back sleepers $2,000
Hybrid mattress This mattress has various layers constructed of different materials, such as foam covering an innerspring core All sleepers $1,650

Bed in a box vs. in-store mattresses

Bed-in-a-box mattresses sold by online mattress stores have become a popular choice among consumers. These mattresses are delivered to your doorstep and arrive compressed inside a fairly small box. They expand over several hours after you unpack them.

Mattress-in-a-box businesses have been winning customer's hearts because of their convenience, budget-friendly prices and delivery speed. However, many people still prefer to buy mattresses in-store because of the range of brands brick-and-mortar stores offer and the ability to test the mattress before buying it.

What is the average mattress price in Tallahassee?

The average price for a queen-size mattress in Tallahassee is around $1,000. While online mattresses tend to be cheaper than those bought at a brick-and-mortar store, costs still vary widely — from less than $200 to $5,000 or more — depending on size, materials, durability and height. A luxury mattress tends to last much longer than a cheap mattress, and you should prepare to spend at least $600 for a quality mattress.

Old mattress removals, shipping costs and in-home assembly can all add to the final price. Some mattresses require a box spring or foundation, which usually cost between $75 and $200. Other mattresses, such as memory foam mattresses, do not require a box spring if used with a platform bed that provides adequate support.

Another way to save on mattresses is to shop in the late winter or early spring when retailers make room for new models. Many companies also offer sales during holidays, such President’s Day and Labor Day weekends and the Fourth of July.

How to buy a mattress in Tallahassee

When looking for the best mattress in Tallahassee, there are several factors to consider to ensure you'll be happy with your purchase. Here are some of the most important:

  • Customer reviews: Looking at what previous customers say about the mattress is a good way to see if the company has good customer service and honors its warranty.
  • Recommendations from your doctor or physical therapist: If you’re purchasing a mattress to help alleviate back pain or joint aches, it’s helpful to talk to someone familiar with your unique situation.
  • Warranty policies: Make sure the company stands behind its products and ask if you’re responsible for shipping on a warranty claim. Most companies offer at least a 10-year warranty.
  • Return policies and trial periods: It takes more than a few nights to decide if a mattress is the best fit for you over time. Many companies offer trial periods of 100 days or more, during which you can return the mattress at no charge if you’re not satisfied.

The Federal Trade Commission also has mattress shopping tips for the consumer. You should also be confident that what you are purchasing is what was described to you. Florida's Bedding Label Act states what information labels must have and where they should be located.

Matress Reviews

Accredited Partner

Saatva Mattress

Saatva Mattress gives Tallahassee residents 120 nights to try out their mattresses. The company offers free white-glove delivery, which includes hand delivery, setup and old mattress removal and makes swapping out mattresses a breeze. Tallahassee reviewers appreciate how the company offers 0 percent APR financing for qualified buyers.

Saatva Mattress Learn More (877) 672-2882
Accredited Partner

Luma Sleep

Luma Sleep offers perks like a 10-year warranty on mattresses and free shipping and returns. The company goes out of its way to provide exceptional service, and its latex and hybrid mattresses are popular with customers. Tallahassee customers recommend Luma’s mattresses for how comfortable and cool they are.

Luma Sleep Learn More (813) 956-3765

Select Comfort - Sleep Number

Sleep Number’s adjustable beds allow couples to have personalized sleeping experiences. Users can also use the company’s smartphone app to find out their nightly SleepIQ score if they purchase the company’s smart bed model. Tallahassee customers appreciate how Sleep Number employees make sure they fully understood how to use the bed’s technology.

Select Comfort - Sleep Number


Purple has innovated the memory foam mattress industry by creating a patented Smart Comfort Grid mattress. The company offers two models of mattresses, and the newer model allows you to choose your level of firmness. Tallahassee customers praise how much support the bed offers while remaining soft and comfortable.

Purple Learn More
Accredited Partner


Casper has three mattress models to choose from, giving you multiple options to fit your budget. Two of the models are available as memory foam or hybrid mattresses. The company’s mattresses are designed in California and free of ozone-depleting chemicals and emissions. Casper mattress users in Tallahassee like how comfortable the company’s mattresses are.

Casper Learn More
Accredited Partner


Nectar gives you one full year to try out your mattress. If you decide at the end of the trial you don't like it, they'll work with you to have it locally donated or disposed of. Nectar's mattresses have a cooling cover and two layers of Gel Memory Foam to circulate air. Tallahassee customers appreciate how the bed keeps them cool in Florida’s warm climate.

Nectar Learn More